Sheila Carver was last seen at the B&B Trailer Park, where she lived with her boyfriend in the Utica area of Seneca, South Carolina, after midnight on June 16, 1998. She left the trailer park in a car with an individual who stated Carver changed her mind and decided to go back home. The driver dropped her off in the Utica Mill Hill area on Goddard Avenue, so she could walk home. She has never been heard from again. Her new car was found parked near her home the next morning.

Her loved ones stated it was uncharacteristic of her to leave without warning. Her disappearance is considered suspicious, and investigators believe she met with foul play and is now deceased.